Top 10 Commercial Truck Insurance Companies

Insurance for motor carriers can be complex, especially for new authorities starting out. Yet without it, your carrier won’t be able to engage with shippers and brokers. Insurance is also required by law for motor carriers to operate. It’s absolutely essential. Whether you’re a fleet manager, owner-operator, or new motor carrier authority, understanding and choosing the right insurance provider is crucial for the protection and success of your operations. 

What insurance does your motor carrier need?

Minimum levels of insurance is mandated by your respective state. Brokers your carrier works with will also have to carry the required insurance coverage as outlined by the brokers. The insurance covers risks like accidents, property damage, and cargo loss. The insurance protects your carrier’s assets and ensures legal compliance. 

Understanding the various types of motor carrier insurance is essential. Here are the primary coverage type to consider and look into:

  • Auto Liability Insurance: Covers bodily injury and property damage caused by your truck while operating.
  • Physical Damage Insurance: Protects your vehicles from damage due to accidents, theft, and natural disasters.
  • Cargo Insurance: Covers the loss or damage to the cargo you are transporting.
  • General Liability: Covers other potential liabilities not directly related to truck operation.
  • Workers’ Compensation: Essential if you have employees.

You can read more for the types of insurance coverage for motor carriers. Don't have your own authority? Read more for the types of insurance coverage for owner-operators.

Top Insurance Providers for Motor Carriers

Finding the right insurance provider is critical for managing risk effectively. Here are some of the top companies offering comprehensive coverage for motor carriers:

1 - HNI

HNI specializes in providing innovative risk services and insurance solutions tailored to the trucking industry. They offer a wide range of coverages, including liability, physical damage, and workers’ compensation, all backed by strong customer support and risk management tools. HNI's team of experts work closely with clients to develop customized plans that address specific risks and operational challenges, ensuring that trucking businesses can operate smoothly and efficiently.

2 - IOA (Insurance Office of America)

IOA offers customized insurance plans for motor carriers, focusing on flexible coverage options and competitive premiums. Known for their exceptional customer service and deep expertise in the trucking industry, IOA takes a consultative approach to understand the unique needs of each client. They provide tailored insurance solutions that not only protect but also help motor carriers manage risks effectively and improve their overall business operations.

3 - Progressive Commercial

Progressive is one of the most well-known providers in commercial trucking insurance. They offer a variety of coverages, including specialized plans for different types of trucking operations, such as long-haul, short-haul, and specialized freight. Their user-friendly online platform allows for easy policy management and claims processing. Comprehensive customer support is available 24/7, making Progressive a popular choice among truckers who value convenience and reliability.

4 - HDVI (High Definition Vehicle Insurance)

HDVI leverages advanced technology to offer dynamic insurance solutions for motor carriers. Their usage-based insurance program adjusts premiums based on real-time data collected from telematics devices, potentially reducing costs and increasing operational efficiency. HDVI's innovative approach provides detailed insights into driving behavior and vehicle performance, enabling motor carriers to make informed decisions that enhance safety and productivity.

5 - DB Schenker

DB Schenker offers a comprehensive insurance package specifically designed for motor carriers. With a global presence and extensive logistics expertise, they provide tailored solutions that address the unique risks and challenges of the trucking industry. Their coverages include liability, physical damage, and specialized cargo insurance, ensuring motor carriers are well-protected against a variety of risks. DB Schenker also emphasizes loss prevention and risk management strategies, helping businesses minimize potential disruptions and maintain smooth operations.

6 - HUB International

HUB International is a leading insurance broker that offers a broad range of insurance and risk management solutions for motor carriers. Their dedicated team of specialists understands the intricacies of the trucking industry and works closely with clients to provide personalized insurance plans. Coverages include auto liability, physical damage, cargo, general liability, and workers’ compensation. HUB International also provides resources and tools to help motor carriers enhance safety, reduce claims, and achieve regulatory compliance.

7 - Sentry Insurance

Sentry Insurance has a long-standing reputation for providing reliable insurance services to the trucking industry. Their comprehensive offerings include auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, and non-trucking liability coverages. Known for their strong customer service and financial stability, Sentry Insurance provides dedicated support to help motor carriers navigate the complexities of insurance requirements. Their risk management services and safety programs are designed to help trucking businesses reduce losses and improve operational efficiency.

8 - National Indemnity Company

National Indemnity Company, a Berkshire Hathaway company, provides specialized insurance solutions for motor carriers of all sizes. They offer a wide variety of coverages, including auto liability, physical damage, cargo, and more. Their strong financial backing and industry expertise make them a reliable choice for trucking businesses seeking comprehensive protection. National Indemnity Company focuses on tailored insurance programs that meet the specific needs of each client, offering flexibility and peace of mind.

9 - Great West Casualty Company

Great West Casualty Company has been serving the trucking industry for decades, earning a reputation for excellence and reliability. Their extensive product lineup includes auto liability, physical damage, cargo insurance, and workers’ compensation. Great West emphasizes safety and loss prevention through comprehensive risk management services and training programs. Their dedicated team works closely with motor carriers to develop effective insurance solutions that enhance safety and protect against potential risks.

10 - Avalon Risk Management

Avalon Risk Management specializes in providing insurance and surety solutions for the transportation and logistics industries. They offer a comprehensive suite of coverages, including auto liability, cargo insurance, and contingent cargo liability. Avalon is known for its innovative products and superior customer service, addressing the unique needs of motor carriers. Their risk management tools and tailored insurance programs are designed to help trucking companies mitigate risks, ensuring smooth and efficient operations. With a focus on personalized service and expertise, Avalon Risk Management helps motor carriers navigate the complexities of the transportation sector while providing robust protection.

Factors to Consider When Choosing an Insurance Provider

Selecting the right insurance provider involves more than just comparing premiums. Here are some critical factors to consider:

  • Trucking Expertise: Trucking insurance is particularly different than most other businesses, so choosing a provider with extensive experience in trucking will be helpful. In particular, there are a lot of different types of coverage to consider, so finding a provider that can address all of a carrier’s needs is important.
  • Customer Service: Look for providers known for their responsive and helpful customer support. You'll be relying on your insurance agent regularly to help with adding additional insured brokers that you plan to haul with.
  • Understanding the Coverage: This may be the most challenging but also critical aspect of . Make sure you understand the coverage and are not underinsured. Also, if there are any exclusions or limitations, make sure you understand them clearly to avoid any surprises in the event of a claim.
  • Working with an Agent:  Insurance agents serve as an intermediary between insurance companies and trucking businesses. They have in-depth knowledge of the insurance market and can help you find the right provider for your specific needs. 
  • Claims Handling Process: In the event of an accident or loss, you'll want a provider with a smooth claims handling process that minimizes disruptions to your operations. Research how different providers handle claims and read reviews from other motor carriers to get an idea.
  • Reliability & Financial Stability: Lastly and most importantly, it's worthwhile to consider if the insurance provider will be around if and/or when a claim comes up.

Choosing the Right Insurance Provider

Choosing the right insurance provider for your motor carrier is a crucial decision that can significantly impact your business operations and financial stability. By understanding the types of insurance needed, considering key factors, and learning from real-life examples, you can make an informed choice that best suits your needs.

For those looking to explore top-tier insurance solutions, consider reaching out to the providers mentioned above. Protect your business, ensure compliance, and gain peace of mind by partnering with the right insurance company.

Related Articles

Insurance for New Motor Carrier Authorities

Insurance for Owner Operators